Saturday, September 15, 2007

Dress Codes and the Decline of Business Teacher Education

Oh my goodness me - what next for business teacher education????

For years business education curriculum at the high school level has been influenced (overly influenced, in my opinion) by the demands of business. Many research studies have been done to determine business needs for their employees and we frequently construct out curriculum based on these findings. Critical thinking about business and its role in society seems to be something that is often missed or actively ignored in favour of creating graduates that fit in.

Why on earth would a business teacher education program mandate a 'business casual' dress code for its students? And to compound matters use a rationale that implies that their graduates will be better off in the business world. I thought the graduates of a business teacher education program were headed for the teaching world where creativity, innovation and yes even dissent were prized.

Do we really want our business education teachers to all be wearing blue blazers, khakis and penny loafers?

Read this and wonder about the future of business education!

This article is from

Business (School) Casual

The College of Business at Illinois State University is taking the imperative to “dress for success” literally. Starting this fall, students majoring in marketing or business teacher education will have to watch what they wear, donning business casual attire in class — or risk getting kicked out for the day.

Business schools offer plenty of reasons to look professional but tend to stop short of requiring a dress code, opting instead to encourage students to look sharp for interviews and meetings with recruiters. While medical schools routinely mandate personal hygiene and clothing guidelines (like these) for students in clinical facilities, and while a number of private religious institutions mandate dress standards, the step is unusual in a classroom setting at a business school.

But college officials have implemented the move, they say, with significant input from the students themselves and a good look at companies’ codes of conduct. The dress code is part of a larger set of standards designed to encourage professionalism and intended to prepare students for the “real world” of business after graduation.

“I think you come in there, you say gosh, it becomes this kind of almost ... mental shift,” said Tim Longfellow, the chairman of the Department of Marketing at Illinois State, which for the time being will be alone in mandating a dress code within the business college. The change was rolled out with a grace period as classes started this week, but beginning next Monday the rules will be in full force — for both students and teachers. The one exception so far is “Introduction to Marketing Management,” because non-majors can take the class.

Business casual for men generally means khakis or cotton pants with a collared button-down shirt or polo; no tie is necessary. For women, cotton pants or skirts are allowed with sweaters, polo shirts and blouses, but the guidelines (reprinted here within a blog post) add more than a few caveats:

* For women, “Solid colors work better than bright patterns.”
* Students will also need to keep up on their dry cleaning (or ironing): “Clothing should be pressed and never wrinkled. Torn, dirty or frayed clothing is unacceptable. All seams must be finished.”
* The types of pants acceptable for men is also clearly delineated: “Slacks that are similar to Dockers and other makers of cotton or synthetic material pants, wool pants, flannel pants, and nice looking dress synthetic pants are acceptable.”
* There is a note of caution on skirts: “Dress and skirt length should be no shorter than four inches above the knee, or a length at which you can sit comfortably in public. Short, tight skirts that ride halfway up the thigh are inappropriate for the classroom.” Longfellow responded to criticisms in an e-mail posted at the College Freedom blog: “I do not ever [see] us getting a ruler out to measure skirt length.”
* “Use common sense when wearing clothing that has words on it; people are easily offended or distracted by words,” the guidelines note, but it’s unclear how a student can wear a shirt that is both collared and bearing offensive language. However, “[c]lothing that has the Illinois State University logo is encouraged. Sports team, university, and fashion brand names on clothing are generally acceptable.”
* If your body is covered in piercings and your hair is spiked and dyed purple, business school may not be the place for you: “Do be aware that as you move into the corporate world, visible body piercing other than pierced ears and visible tattoos may not be considered appropriate by some of the firms you want to work for.”
* “Hats are not appropriate in the classroom,” but “[h]ead covers that are required for religious purposes or to honor cultural tradition are allowed.”

Administrators’ and faculty members’ arguments for the dress code are forceful. “They’re in a preprofessional environment; it’s not like a light switch gets flipped and you go from being students to a competent professional,” said Amy Humphreys, assistant to the college dean for constituent relations. “You can already just feel the difference [in attitude] between the kids who just come shuffling in with iPods and flip-flops, and then students who come in dressed for success.”

Students, who found out about the changes in a letter over the summer, are somewhat split on the issue. Chrystal Caban, a senior who is president of the college’s American Marketing Association chapter, said she normally has worn sweatpants and a T-shirt to class, “and I’ve always considered myself a good student.” She conceded that she doesn’t feel strongly either way and can see the merits of both sides.

But Rob Duerr, a junior who is president of the Collegiate Entrepreneurs’ Organization (CEO), implied that students who have trouble with the policy are acting out of laziness. He said there was also an added benefit for outside visitors to the college, such as recruiters, who “come and they see everyone dressed up and they get a better impression of what’s going on.”

The dress code grew from a larger effort to adopt wide-ranging standards of professional behavior and ethical conduct, which urge students (and professors) to “[d]ress appropriately, avoiding clothing that is revealing, provocative, or includes offensive language or visuals.” Norris Porter, assistant to the dean for student services, said the standards came about after the major business scandals earlier this decade and the financial decline in the wake of September 11. Colleges felt pressure from corporations, he said, which wanted to know how students were being prepared for the moral responsibilities awaiting them after graduation.

“In light of that, the college took the perspective that most corporations have these standards or codes of conduct or ‘how we do business’ statements, and we decided we’d do our own,” Porter said.

Before being taken department-wide, the dress code was first required in individual marketing classes starting in 2003. Last fall, all courses in the professional sales sequence followed suit (as some other similar tracks have done within other schools, Longfellow said). “Inputs from students and faculty alike have been extremely positive,” the guidelines state. “All have indicated that the professionalism exhibited in the class led to a better learning environment, students being better prepared for class, and students being more respectful of one another.”

Once the grace period this week is over, professors can theoretically ask students they consider to be in violation of the guidelines to leave the room, meaning they could lose credit for any work that day. Longfellow emphasized that there would be an appeals process and that students can speak with their professors if there is a misunderstanding, but said the department was still deciding whether a repeat offender could eventually be removed from his or her major. Caban suggested that some professors might enforce the policy more leniently than others, a possibility that might cause some students to choose their classes more strategically.

Other criticisms came from online, where the College Freedom blog suggested that the policy would disproportionately affect poorer students: “Buying business casual clothing may force already impoverished students to go into debt.” Longfellow said he hasn’t heard any complaints yet. “The thing is, you can look very nicely in business casual and not really spend a lot of money either,” he said — less than what it costs to buy designer jeans, he added.

Illinois State’s status as a public university presents another potential complication, although Longfellow said the policy passed muster with the legal team. Since students apply specifically to the program within the university, there wasn’t an issue of stifling expression, he said.

— Andy Guess

To read an interesting critique of this action as an infringement on academic freedom (and freedom in general) go to the blog called College Freedom.

Labels: ,


Anonymous Lona said...

Oh gosh...nice that the white middle-upper class is keeping a firm hold on education.

9:46 AM  
Blogger Mike said...

We're generally going to become teachers and teachers dress in a wide variety of ways.

9:16 AM  
Blogger He Said... She Said said...

I went to a high school where a dress code was mandatory. I liked it as it reduced the bullying because of class. Everyone was wearing the exact same thing bought from the exact same store.

In this instance I disagree with it. I like wearing casual clothing (jeans, comfortable shirts etc.) and enjoyed my internship at Usher because it was a very laid back and casual school. There were days I dressed up more, but when I did wear a tie it was usually a fun novelty tie (most likely Spider-Man, Batman or Superman) and the kids always got a hoot out of it (at my expense usually).

Long post short, I disagree with forcing business ed teachers to dress a certain way, especially if the school has it's own informal culture, as the one I was at did.

2:40 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

great read. I would love to follow you on twitter.

10:23 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

free dating websites [url=]adult personals[/url] jackson area christian singles yahoo singles

3:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi all,
I found very good source of finding dofollow high parerank backlinks. Even from real PR10.
I cant imagine value of a real pr10.

I would like to share with you all about how i succeded to rank on 1st page on google.

6:38 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Looking for [url=]viagra[/url] ?Help of Our Uncouth Prices at, The Distinguished [b][url=]Online Chemist's snitch on [/url][/b] To [url=]Buy Viagra[/url] Online ! You Can also Look like to Ok dippy Deals When You [url=]Buy Cialis[/url] and When You You [url=]Buy Levitra[/url] Online. We Also Be subjected to a Ginormous Generic [url=]Phentermine[/url] On account of Your Victuals ! We Knuckle under up Suspect [url=]Viagra[/url] and Also [url=]Generic Viagra[/url] !

10:36 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mount the animal with two backs casinos? log in inquire into this advanced [url=]online casino[/url] sway and posteriors a endure up online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at .
you can also validate our untrained [url=]casino[/url] undertone at and glory win corporeal notes !
another fashion [url=]casino spiele[/url] esteem is , because german gamblers, get onto not ornate online casino bonus.

2:28 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Correctly your article helped me very much in my college assignment. Hats afar to you send, intention look audacious for the duration of more cognate articles in a jiffy as its anecdote of my favourite issue to read.

10:17 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

lose your erection after cumming [url=]tegretol[/url] frys pharmacy in tucson blood tests take a stand against drugs
dobbin diet [url=]beconase aq[/url] allegany home health software [url=]anxiety cure disorder[/url]

11:16 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

drug hair tests [url=]femme d amelioration[/url] war on drugs facts phosophoros annd health
control of substances hazardous to health regulations 1991 [url=]fluoxetine[/url] ritalin depression [url=]kidney disease urine foam[/url]

10:32 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

short and long term affects of smoking [url=]septilin[/url] blood pressure variations throughout the body temple of health tea bags
kathleen goings medical corps [url=]No prescription online pharmacy[/url] leisure centre medicine hat [url=]westlife total eclips of the heart mp3[/url]

10:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

medical jewellery australia [url=]hytrin[/url] oral blood blister atkins extreme weight loss
admissions to meharry medical college [url=]medications without a prescription[/url] herpes yeast infection [url=]diet plan for diaes type 1[/url]

11:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

sample muscle tests [url=]casodex[/url] reliance drug rehabilitation center pro active sports medicine
medical sarafanim [url=]Order Cheap Generic Drugs[/url] codes and covenants for medical parks [url=]post tramutic stress[/url]

12:03 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

diabetes japan [url=]brand tamiflu[/url] should smoking be illegal in public dissertation on smoking room ventilation
blood on the sheets [url=]depakote[/url] accepted heat of solution for calcium chloride [url=]what is the kidney disease lsgs[/url]

2:21 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

breast cancer gene [url=]anti champignons[/url] breast enlargement risks viagra cheapest
pacific county health department [url=]inderal[/url] inderal and anxiety [url=]chewing gum keeps you awake[/url]

2:38 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

dickinson iron district health department [url=]cytoxan[/url] community health centre california medical marijaunna
hills scientic diet [url=]propecia[/url] slim fast diet before and after photos [url=]lakeview medical center web ticket[/url]

11:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

diet download free kazaa [url=]disfunzione erettile[/url] big truck little penis types of sperformance enhancing drugs
lighthouse clinic depression wisconsin [url=]levlen[/url] red ear syndrome [url=]clarion medical group indianapolis[/url]

11:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

free diet profile [url=]No prescription online pharmacy[/url] diet before heart surgery patterson medical clinic
smoke flavor and single malt scotch wisky [url=]Buy generic and brand medications[/url] medical billing compliance [url=]thyroid high blood pressure caffine[/url]

10:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]online testosterone pharmacy[/url] drug bust in new london ct [url=]dunne and fda and british[/url]
drugs in the prison systems
[url=]drug test prescription[/url] dollar amount americans pay for illegal drugs [url=]actos aciphex aciphex nasacort ambien[/url]
dinny addicts lost wood insurance money drugs druggie full give
[url=]tri county family medicine[/url] drug awareness cheer for kindergarten [url=]acetazolamide ext rel[/url] buy discount viagra [url=]doxil with cytoxan[/url]

10:30 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]is drug addiction a choice or disease[/url] still want drugstore [url=]side affects of reglan[/url]
cheap nursing drug book
[url=]the obra law and its significance to pharmacy[/url] drugs and nursing implications 9th edition [url=]avodart cheapen price propecia proscar[/url]
nursing student drug card helps
[url=]teen drug abuse steroids[/url] analysis of misuse of drugs act [url=]moderate alzheimer restlessness[/url] erectile dysfunction correction [url=]acomplia rimonabant[/url]

10:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

social anxiety disorder assessment questions [url=]mentat[/url] centre ofr child and adolesent health bristol dog penis problems
how to bring up low blood levels [url=]general de salud[/url] new jersey department of health [url=]tucson medical center[/url]

10:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Not sure where to post this but I wanted to ask if anyone has heard of National Clicks?

Can someone help me find it?

Overheard some co-workers talking about it all week but didn't have time to ask so I thought I would post it here to see if someone could help me out.

Seems to be getting alot of buzz right now.


1:33 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

6:55 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=]Online Video Downloader[/url] [url=]CameraMover[/url]
WinTVZilla Video Fixer dvdXsoft 3GP Video Converter 1.20
[url=]Easy DVD Shrink[/url] [url=]N1 Video Converter[/url]
DVD X Studios CloneDVD Joboshare AVI MPEG Converter 3Q 3GP Video Converter
Kingdia DVD to MP4 Converter 1.5.10
my icq:858499940385

3:43 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

viagra prescription online [url=]pharmacy discounts[/url] tea cup poodle chew toys student health and fitness tips
drugs the sims 2 [url=]urispas[/url] complete dental care lakewood [url=]dental insuance plan of nys[/url]

9:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]bare metal stents vs drug eluting[/url] cialis and levitra [url=]order casodex mail[/url]
grants available for young people fighting drug addiction
[url=]online pharmacy prescription drug viagra[/url] drug and alcohol addiction therapy [url=]fexofenadine rx[/url]
abbot labs internship pharmacy
[url=]baggies used for drugs[/url] london uk buy generic viagra [url=]dose adjustment of clarithromycin[/url] cirrhosis and prescription drugs side effects [url=]effect flonase side[/url]

4:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]highly protein bound drugs[/url] what is levitra [url=]nystatin and triamcinolone acetonide ointment[/url]
city of detroit health department map
[url=]london uk buy generic viagra[/url] borderline personality disorder drugs [url=]health services sistersville wv[/url]
filled prescription drugs records kept
[url=]jersey drug dealer[/url] illegal drug usage [url=]anacin calendar[/url] joe kelley of eli lilly drugs [url=]ndc number for toradol[/url]

2:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]pregabalin drug interactions[/url] robbery of pharmacy by ryan salim [url=]olanzapine drug[/url]
depression drugs zoloft
[url=]cialis guidelines[/url] neurogenesis supplements and drugs [url=]alicia keys from the heart[/url]
drug book somordren
[url=]abuses to adhd drugs[/url] who started the war on drugs [url=]new york state medical restriction drivers license[/url] pharmacy interview questions [url=]stop smoking[/url]

3:31 PM  
Anonymous alan said...

2 Online Training Education

Whether you are thinking about getting your bachelor’s, masters or doctorate degree, online education can be a great option for anyone with a busy life. When you are a parent or a busy career person, it can be hard to go back to school. Maybe you feel that too much time has passed since you were last in college or high school, and you would feel uncomfortable in a formal education setting……………

top education

3:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

simrad yp 500 auto pilot volkswagen jetta diesel mpg
[url=]automobile navigation systems reviews[/url] auto test example [url=]land rover rental mozambique[/url]
dodge caravan tire size
[url=]how to remove 2006 dodge radio[/url] mercedes benz replace battery reset abs [url=]harmon kardon replacement speakers range rover[/url]
edwards automobile history
[url=]used mercedes gl450[/url] automobile protection corporation [url=]peugeot benzine voorschrift[/url]

1:13 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sorry for my bad english. Thank you so much for your good post. Your post helped me in my college assignment, If you can provide me more details please email me.

4:53 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

travel checks travel agency saskatoon
[url=]travel insurance for resident of france[/url] festival travel [url=]airfare car rental[/url]
roc travel agent
[url=]ctv travel channel[/url] winslow travel [url=]expedia reviews[/url]
xbox time travel
[url=]kansas travel guide[/url] europe travel with kids [url=]which is better airbus boeing[/url] celiac blog travel [url=]sands motel caddillac[/url]
book summery for travel team mike lupica [url=]northwest airline blog[/url]
big sky travel trailers
[url=]canadian federal site for pet travel to uk[/url] buy used travel trailer [url=]caledonian cruise[/url]
[url=]camoing bus tour[/url] abudabi travel agencies [url=]airlines reno[/url] gold pond cruffs travel [url=]adventure list[/url]
zelco travel [url=]delta airline arrivals[/url]

3:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

maine automobile salvage prices automobile saturn history sales
[url=]special purpose machine for automobile components[/url] mercedes 600 1967 [url=]sr20 motors for sale[/url]
music to make volkswagen by
[url=]hyundai genesis detroit auto show[/url] used mercedes gloucestershire [url=]mazda 323f manuals[/url]
dodge ram 250 1991 parts diagram
[url=]volkswagen beetle forums[/url] new mercedes c class [url=]peugeot[/url]

9:44 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

dodge ram dually conversion bayliss auto vent opener
[url=]online auto repair books[/url] mercedes castro canciones [url=]scion finance ca deals[/url]
mercedes benz e270cdi 2110161a488154
[url=]tomtom auto power on[/url] compare land rovers and mercedes [url=]ktm supermoto suit[/url]
pentax compatible auto focus 35mm lens
[url=]mercedes charity[/url] how often for auto oil change [url=]lancia integrale[/url]

1:14 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

rohde shoes weather chanel greece [url=]make clothes color fast[/url] mother of the groom fashions payless shoes coupon [url=]charles klein clothing[/url]

10:08 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

tubbs snowshoes news in the fashion business [url=]discovery chanel[/url] lauren kritzman old fashioned pendant lamp shades [url=]atmosphere ralph lauren carpet[/url]

10:26 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

jodan team flow shoes plus size designercocktail dresses [url=]plus size fashions[/url] the weather chanel maggie sweet fashions [url=]strite rite munchkin shoes[/url]

9:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

comfortable flat shoes flat metallic shoes [url=]designer replics handbags[/url] dogs clothes learn to make clothes [url=]laurens county sc public records[/url]

9:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

laurent flochel cnrs lauren crane [url=]zara clothes[/url] chanel myspace layouts fun online fashion design game [url=]jennifer mingucci[/url]

10:29 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

home movie adult [url=]double dribble[/url] bottoms up movie deauxma full free movie
office space movie [url=]basic instinct 2[/url] watch all of the simpsons movie the movie stay alive
free online movie of ann of green gables [url=]going overboard[/url] billy talent song in a movie soundtrack
the movie cars party invitation printable free [url=]shandra the jungle girl[/url] sky high the movie in her shoes movie
the pink orchid movie [url=]the stned age[/url] kidnapped movie hot box invasion movie

1:20 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home